Brian is live
Brian is now answering your questions about the Edinburgh fringe.
Share
Key events
Any advice for young comedians?
TheHound asks: What advice would you give to young people who want to be comedians?
Brian:
double quotation markGig. Get up on stage at open mic nights, and give it a go. Over and again. Most comedians would say that it x-hundred gigs’ worth of trying and failing and refining before your comic voice fully emerges (assuming it ever does…) and you learn how to operate in dialogue with the room. Arguably more than other art forms comedy is a skill that can’t really be developed anywhere other than in dialogue with an audience.
So: perform! And go watch lots of comedy too. And don’t try and be anybody but yourself.
Share
Are writing and delivery equally important?
JamesMoriarty asks: Can a good performance rescue less-than-stellar material, or are writing and delivery equally important?
Brian:
double quotation markYes, of course a good performance can (substantially) redeem sub-par material. Hard to quantify the relative importance of writing and delivery, and the dream of course is that both are top-notch and working in perfect harmony.
But I’ve enjoyed plenty shows by acts who blaze with performing flair even when their material is so-so. And likewise, shows by acts who write brilliant jokes, even if they don’t sell them as vivaciously as other performers might.
Share
Can material be separated from the artist delivering it?
GlenWright1975 asks: Do you think Amanda Knox’s show will be judged fairly and without bias? Over the years we’ve all built up an opinion of her, and I wonder if reviewers/audiences can separate that from the quality of her material?
double quotation markBrian: It’s hard bordering on impossible to review without bringing some biases and preconceptions to the process. The best reviewers will at least be aware of these and try and acknowledge or mitigate them. It looks (judging from the blurb) like Amanda Knox’s show is going to be upfront about her public history, which brings that history even more into the scope of what the critic will be writing about.
I don’t think it’s the critic’s job, or certainly not their most interesting one, to adjudicate on the rights and wrongs of whether Knox should be performing the show in the first place. But if that question, and others relating to what we know of her life, feel like they’re genuinely affecting how one experiences the show (and how it feels it’s landing in the room), it would be disingenuous of the reviewer not to address that.
Share
Updated at 14.39 CEST
Who should’ve won a Comedy Award but didn’t?
Pgetz1 asks: What act or show(s) have been most unfairly overlooked for a Comedy Award nomination in your years of covering the festival?
Brian:
double quotation markHow long have you got?! Last year gave us a prime example, when the American comedy/cabaret act Cat Cohen had the most fantastic show in town by a mile, and was overlooked. (The fact that no one is entirely clear on the award’s eligibility criteria doesn’t help.)
The phenomenon isn’t unique to Edinburgh comedy, but choices made by committee are often compromise choices, and acts that are brilliant but idiosyncratic find themselves sidelined. At any event, the majority of the incontrovertibly great acts and shows I’ve seen at the fringe over the years have been pipped to or wholly overlooked by the awards – or, as sometimes happens, offered the sop of the so-called Panel Prize.
Examples include Bo Burnham’s Words Words Words in 2010; Rhod Gilbert’s 2008 show The Award-Winning Mince Pie; Natalie Palamides’ hot-button and hilarious Nate; and one of the all-time great sketch shows, Pappy’s Last Show Ever, in 2012. Then there’s peak Doug Stanhope. Kate Berlant. The once-seen, never-forgotten Hans Teeuwen. Flight of the Conchords. The Pajama Men. Adrienne Truscott’s extraordinary feminist show (and Panel Prize recipient) Asking For It. Some were nominated; none won.
Share
If populism is popular, where is all the populist comedy?
Wateroffaducksback asks: If populism is so popular, why is there so little comedy about populists? By definition it is not niche but they all seem to be comedians and tick all the boxes – exposing hypocrisy, pretension, injustice, absurdity, irony…
Brian:
double quotation markIf by this question you mean, ‘where’s all the right-wing / populist comedy?’, well, there’s plenty of it around – although the Edinburgh fringe isn’t the best place to find it. Jimmy Carr, Ricky Gervais, Dave Chappelle – some of the biggest comedy acts in the world pander to populist sentiment. And that’s before you even mention the Jim Davidsons and Roy Chubby Browns beloved of the Reform brigade.
Even on the fringe, there’s an upcoming generation – the likes of Vittorio Angelone, or his slight senior Geoff Norcott – whose ‘saying the unsayable’ material knowingly flirts with populist ideas. And there are regular visits by old-school comics (Bobby Davro was one recent example) whose shtick would be right up Nigel Farage’s street.
So, the idea that comedy is in some kind of left-wing stranglehold is a nonsense, although I’d agree that the fringe, where the acts (and audiences) tend younger and more idealistic, self-selects against that kind of comic.
Share
Is the fringe now just for visitors and ‘the industry’?
WolfFlow asks: Having lived in Edinburgh for more than 30 years, is it safe to say that the Fringe is for tourists and “the industry”?
Brian:
double quotation markI don’t believe that’s the case. I grew up in Fife, my family are still there, and I’ve got family and friends in Edinburgh too. They all go to fringe events every year, as I did when with my pals when I was a teenager.
In my experience, it’s an unhelpful myth, usually propagated by people with little love for the arts, that Edinburgh residents don’t like the fringe. Some don’t, I’m sure. But many do, and are proud and delighted that their city hosts the biggest and best performing arts festival in the world.
Share
Brian is live
Brian is now answering your questions about the Edinburgh fringe.
Share
Welcome to the Conversation
Join us at 1pm (BST) on Tuesday 4 August, as the Guardian’s comedy critic Brian Logan answers your questions about Scotland’s singular performing arts festival.
In his many years of covering the fringe, Brian has seen it change and grow, and break stars and shows alike. But in a Guardian column four years ago he wrote that “in recent years, my enthusiasm has been increasingly smothered by caveats: that the fringe is too absurdly expensive for artists, to a degree that excludes many; that it’s insufficiently diverse; that it can be overwhelming, gruelling and lonely for many of the people taking part” and that it “must change or die”. Have the past few editions changed his mind? And this year, with dynamic pricing being trialled, will there be questions about who the fringe is for?
Please post your questions for Brian below now.
Share
Updated at 13.30 CEST
Source:
www.theguardian.com
